Threads vs Reddit – which is best for public conversation?

Instagram Threads vs Reddit: which public conversation platform is better?

Threads vs Reddit - Which platform is best for public conversation? Image shows text "Threads vs Reddit - Which platform is best for public conversation?", next to the Reddit and Threads logos with a VS graphic between them.

You can trust PC GuideOur team of experts use a combination of independent consumer research, in-depth testing where appropriate – which will be flagged as such, and market analysis when recommending products, software and services. Find out how we test here.

Last Updated on

If you enjoy engaging in public conversations online, you might have encountered two popular platforms: Threads and Reddit. Both platforms allow people to share ideas, ask questions, and participate in discussions. Reddit has become something of a cult staple, with a figure of about 430 million monthly active users. However, Threads has been created by industry giant Meta, owner of Instagram and Facebook. It gained a shocking 10 million users within the first 7 hours of release, a number that will only continue to increase as people test out the Twitter alternative. This article will compare Threads vs Reddit in selected categories to determine which is best suited for public conversation and community building. So let’s dive in and explore the features and benefits of each platform.

Interface & Usability

Threads

With Threads, you can easily navigate discussions using a clean and intuitive interface. You can explore various topics and follow Threads users that interest you. The platform offers a user-friendly experience, making it simple to participate in conversations. Furthermore, as it is a companion app to Instagram, you are able to transfer your Instagram followers onto Threads to kickstart your engagement on the platform.

Reddit

On the other hand, Reddit presents its content in a structured manner through subreddits. Each subreddit focuses on a specific topic, ensuring that discussions remain relevant. While the interface might initially seem overwhelming due to its extensive content, once you get the hang of it, Reddit becomes a valuable tool for engaging with diverse communities.

Community & Engagement

Threads

Threads is designed to foster meaningful interactions within its community. You can connect with like-minded individuals, join groups, and follow specific topics. The platform encourages respectful dialogue, making it a welcoming space for all users. However, one thing that is noticeably lacking from this Twitter Alternative is hashtags. Although users can connect, there is currently a reliance on an algorithm to engage with content, with no use of hashtags or a ‘trending’ section to find community-relevant topics.

Reddit

Reddit boasts a vast user base and hosts countless communities, covering almost any subject you can imagine. Its “upvote” and “downvote” system allows users to determine the visibility of posts and comments, promoting community-driven moderation. You can build a reputation and gain recognition within the Reddit community by actively participating and contributing.

Anonymity & Privacy

Threads

As a companion app to Instagram, you currently have to have an Instagram account to access Threads. This means that you are not really able to use the app anonymously unless you decide to make a new Instagram account with a different username. Additionally, Threads does have a rather extensive privacy policy that collects lots of personal data. However, given that Threads uses the same policy as Instagram, there is no solid reason to suggest it isn’t safe.

Reddit

While Reddit allows users to maintain anonymity, it also offers the option to create a profile with a username. This allows users to establish an online presence and develop a reputation within the communities they engage with. Anonymity can be particularly useful for individuals who prefer to discuss sensitive topics or share personal experiences without fear of judgment or repercussions. Like any online platform, Reddit collects data from you and uses it in accordance with its Privacy Policy, but it does not seem to have the extensive data requirements that Threads does.

Moderation & Content Control

Threads

Threads ensures a safe environment for public conversation through active moderation. The platform’s moderators monitor discussions and remove any content that violates their guidelines. This dedication to maintaining a positive atmosphere contributes to the overall quality of conversations on Threads.

Reddit

As a user-driven platform, Reddit relies on community members to report and address any content that violates the site’s rules. While Reddit has a team of moderators overseeing the platform, the responsibility for content control largely rests on the users. This can lead to varied experiences, depending on the specific subreddit and its moderation practices.

Conclusion – Threads vs Reddit

Both Threads and Reddit offer unique features and benefits for engaging in public conversations. Threads provides a clean interface and user-friendly experience, with the encouragement of respectful dialogue. On the other hand, Reddit’s extensive communities and voting system empower users to shape the content and discussions they engage with.

Ultimately, the choice between Threads vs Reddit depends on your preferences and the specific conversation you seek. If you value simplicity and a more curated experience, Threads might be the right fit for you. However, if you enjoy exploring diverse topics and communities and appreciate the power of community-driven moderation, Reddit can offer a rich and dynamic experience. If you’re interested in conversational apps, you can read about Twitter vs Threads. We’ve also been covering other conversational text-based apps that have been coming up to rival Twitter, such as Mastodon and Bluesky Social.

FAQs:

Are there any age restrictions on Threads and Reddit?

Both Threads and Reddit have age restrictions in place. Threads requires users to be at least 16 years old to create an account and participate in discussions. 

On the other hand, Reddit requires users to be at least 13 years old. It is important to adhere to these age restrictions and ensure you comply with the platform’s terms of service when using Threads or Reddit.

Marla writes across a wide range of topics across PC Guide, including AI, PC hardware, and news on the latest tech releases. She's a passionate writer that's interested in the future of technology.