Home > News

Spotlight turns to AMD as Puget Systems report showcases CPU failure rates by generation

Puget Systems highlights AMD failure rates
Last Updated on August 5, 2024
Eyes Turn to AMD as Intel Problems Swirl Out of Control
PC Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read More
You can trust PC Guide: Our team of experts use a combination of independent consumer research, in-depth testing where appropriate - which will be flagged as such, and market analysis when recommending products, software and services. Find out how we test here.

The cracks are starting to show in Intel’s latest generation of processors, with the brand experiencing setback after setback. Reports of widespread instability and failures with the 13th and 14th generation chips have sent waves through the PC community, with some high-profile users reporting failure rates as high as 50%. While the issue is pretty serious, a new report from custom PC builder Puget Systems adds an intriguing twist. While confirming that they too have experienced elevated failure rates with Intel’s newest chips, their numbers are significantly lower than those reported by others.

Puget Systems attributes this discrepancy to its conservative approach to power management. Unlike some users and system builders who push their hardware to the limit, Puget has opted for a more cautious strategy, adhering closely to Intel’s recommended settings. This, they believe, has helped to mitigate some of the issues plaguing other users.

Image Source: Puget Systems

Spotlight turns to AMD

Interestingly, the report also reveals that AMD’s Ryzen 5000 and 7000 series processors have actually experienced higher failure rates than Intel’s troubled 13th and 14th generation chips. However, there’s a crucial caveat: the majority of these AMD failures occurred within Puget Systems’ own facilities, rather than in customers’ hands. This suggests a potential manufacturing or handling issue specific to Puget’s operations, rather than a widespread problem with AMD chips.

Intel has acknowledged the issue with its latest processors and is promising a microcode update in mid-August to address the problem. However, the company has been clear that this patch will prevent future degradation, but won’t reverse any damage that has already occurred.

Problems with pushing to the limit

While the situation is definitely concerning for Intel, it has also shone a spotlight on the potential vulnerabilities of pushing hardware to its absolute limits. Puget Systems’ experience highlights the importance of a balanced approach to system building, prioritizing stability over raw performance.

As the dust settles on this Intel debacle, it’s worth noting that AMD, despite its own issues, has largely avoided the same level of scrutiny. With Intel’s reputation taking a significant hit, it will be interesting to see if this opens up an opportunity for AMD to capitalize on the situation and gain market share. Ultimately, the focus for both Intel and AMD should be on delivering reliable, long-lasting products. Consumers deserve better than to be faced with the prospect of their expensive hardware failing prematurely.

Tom is a tech writer with a detailed view on ensuring the best buying advice, most useful information, and latest news makes its way into PC Guide's articles.