Learn about the technologies behind the Internet with The TCP/IP Guide!
NOTE: Using robot software to mass-download the site degrades the server and is prohibited. See here for more.
Find The PC Guide helpful? Please consider a donation to The PC Guide Tip Jar. Visa/MC/Paypal accepted.
View over 750 of my fine art photos any time for free at DesktopScenes.com!

[ The PC Guide | Systems and Components Reference Guide | Hard Disk Drives | Hard Disk Logical Structures and File Systems | New Technology File System (NTFS) | NTFS Security and Permissions ]

Ownership and Permission Assignment

Permissions and permission groups control access to files and folders on NTFS volumes, but what controls who can assign permissions? Would you really be surprised if I told you that it was, in fact, other permissions? :^) Yes, that is indeed the case. These special permissions work in combination with another key NTFS security concept: ownership.

Every object within the NTFS volume has an owner, which is a user identified by the object as being the one who controls it. By default, the user who creates a file or folder becomes its owner. The significance of ownership is that the owner of a file or folder always has the ability to assign permissions for that object. The owner can decide what permissions should be applied to the object, controlling others' access to the file or folder.

The two special permissions that are associated with ownership and permission assignment are "Change Permissions" (P) and "Take Ownership" (O). If a user is granted the "Change Permissions" permission, the user can change the permission settings for the object even if he or she does not own it. If a user has "Take Ownership" permission, the user has the ability to take over ownership of the resource, and of course, once it is owned the user can do anything he or she wants with the permissions. Both of these special permissions are most commonly granted through the standard permission group "Full Control". Note that ownership of an object cannot be assigned or given away. The owner of the object can only give the right to others to take ownership. There's an important but subtle distinction there. :^)

Deciding how to assign permissions to various files and folders is an important system administration task. Very careful thought needs to go into how user groups are created and permissions assigned to various objects. One common mistake that many administrators make is misusing the "No Access" permission group under Windows NT. If used incorrectly, this can lock everyone out of large areas of an NTFS volume. Problems can also occur if different users take ownership of files or change permissions when they should not--this is in fact the reason for the distinction between the "Full Control" permission group, and the slightly more restricted groups "Change" or "Modify". One should be very careful when granting "Full Control" permission. Note that by default, members of the "Administrators" user group can always take ownership of, or change permissions on, any file or folder. This allows administrators to fix permission problems if they occur.

The mechanics of assigning permission are rather straight-forward. The most common method is to right-click an object in the Windows Explorer, select Properties, and then click the "Security" tab to access the permissions settings for the object. The exact way that permissions are assigned depends on whether you are using Windows NT or Windows 2000. Since I have already probably gone into far too much detail on permissions, I am not going to delve into the details on exactly how permissions are set. However, I do think it's important to highlight that the NT and 2000 permissions models work differently in one fundamental respect.

Under Windows NT, there is really only one kind of permission assignment possible. Generally speaking, you can only "allow" users to do things. For example, you can allow someone read permission on a folder. By not granting the write permission as well, the system infers that the person may not write the folder. However, there is no way to explicit say "no write permission on this folder for this user". The difference is important, because it has implications in multiple-level hierarchies of folders. The only way to disallow access to something in the Windows NT NTFS security model is to use the "No Access" permission group. This group will over-ride any "allow" permissions also defined for the object, and cut off access to the item for the user or group who is tagged with "No Access". Unfortunately, this is a sledgehammer: it takes away all permissions. There is no way to explicitly select a folder and say "regardless of other permission settings and groups that User X may be in, X may not write any files in this folder".

Windows 2000 greatly improved the control you have in assigning NTFS permissions by creating two explicit settings for each permission and permission group: allow and deny. Using these setting types, it is easy to specifically allow read access and deny write access to a file or folder, enabling the example I just mentioned above to be implemented. This improved control is also the reason why the "No Access" group does not exist in Windows 2000: it isn't needed. Windows 2000 has specific rules for dealing with the various access and deny permission settings that may be set on objects or inherited by them, especially when they may conflict. See the discussion of advanced inheritance for more information on this.

Tip: Windows NT 4.0 users can gain the advantages of the Windows 2000 permission assignment method by installing Service Pack 4 or later and using the Security Configuration Manager (SCM).

Next: Static Permission Inheritance

Home  -  Search  -  Topics  -  Up

The PC Guide (http://www.PCGuide.com)
Site Version: 2.2.0 - Version Date: April 17, 2001
Copyright 1997-2004 Charles M. Kozierok. All Rights Reserved.

Not responsible for any loss resulting from the use of this site.
Please read the Site Guide before using this material.
Custom Search